Bedbugs—just the mention can start people scratching. But in the fight to control these blood-sucking, bedroom dwelling pests, a Union professor’s research, recently published in the Journal of Medical Entomology, drew attention from news outlets around the world.
Dr. Corraine McNeill joined the Union College faculty in 2012 to teach biology, shortly after finishing her research and completing her doctoral studies seeking to understand how bedbugs react to different colors.
Her tests demonstrated that bedbugs do have a color preference. “Most of the time they preferred red and black, but other colors such as orange can also be appealing,” McNeill explained. The results showed the color preference for baby bedbugs changed throughout each stage and bedbugs have a preference of colors based on whether they were fed or starved.“It is important to know what color harborage bedbugs prefer because it allows us to learn where they are likely to hide and even lay their eggs” she said.
How do you love bugs?
McNeill’s classes at Union reflect her affinity for creepy crawlies. Besides teaching general biology, human biology, and principals of entomology, she started a new class at Union: insects and you. But she didn’t start out that way.
After graduating from Glenmuir High School in her native Jamaica, McNeill thought she wanted to become a physician. “I decided to attend a liberal arts college in the United States and then decide for sure about medical school,” she said.
Halfway through her time at Randolph-Macon Woman’s College (now Randolph College) in Virginia, she started studying slugs with one of the professors and fell in love with research. “I realized I was more interested in pursuing organisms related to medical research than in becoming a physician,” McNeill said.
After starting graduate studies at Virginia Commonwealth University, she hoped to find a place to study slugs, but without success. Her advisor suggested a switch to insects. “She told me they were similar to slugs agriculturally but a lot more diverse,” McNeill explained.She finished a master’s degree at the University of Florida and began doctoral studies researching chemicals to control the pepper weevil. But many of the chemicals made her sick, and after three years she couldn’t take it anymore.“Where do you want me to go, God?” she asked, frustrated with her studies.
He led her to the Urban Entomology program under the tutelage of Dr. Phil Koehler and Dr. Roberto Pereira to study bedbug behavior and bedbug education.“I was still at the University of Florida, and I really wanted to finish my doctorate,” she said. “And I did not realize the broad impact that bedbugs had.”But as she dug deeper, she began to see the importance of bedbug research.“Looking back, I really think it was God’s leading,” McNeill said. “Bedbugs are pests of medical significance. I ended up doing exactly what I felt called to do back as an undergraduate without realizing it.”
As she searched for a research project for her doctoral dissertation, her advisor, Dr. Philip Koehler asked if colors were important to bedbugs.“I don’t know,” McNeill answered. At first, she thought the idea silly until she remembered other hematophagous, insects that suck blood, can see color. Koehler had set up a very large bedbug colony, so McNeill had plenty of specimens to study.
Since bedbugs are blood suckers, they leave bites and everyone reacts to these bites differently. “Bedbugs are considered a nuisance because they are very small and inconspicuous and you hardly notice them. By the time you notice it may be too late,” McNeill explained. “Bedbugs have proven resistant to various chemicals, so the only real effective non-chemical way to kill them is by using heat—approximately 120 degrees Fahrenheit for several hours.”
McNeill cut out hundreds of two centimeter-square tents from different color paper. She and her team tested bedbugs from the time they were hatched through the five stages of babyhood and as adults. The parameters of the experiment included testing babies just hatched—before and after they were fed. Then they looked at each consecutive stage of growth, and when they became adults, she looked at both females and males in groups and by themselves.
“We started out looking at two colors,” said McNeill. “We knew white was our standard and then we tested red, orange, yellow, blue, green, lilac, and violet.” They knew bedbugs are nocturnal, so the first experiments took place in the dark, and the results showed no specific color preference. Once the lights were turned on, the results changed drastically. “We gave them the same sequence of colors with the lights on and they would choose a particular color.”
They discovered bedbugs tend to prefer red and black, and tend to stay away from green and yellow. “I always joke with people, ‘Make sure you get yellow sheets!’” said McNeill. “But to be very honest, I think that would be stretching the results a little too much. I think using colors to monitor and prevent bedbugs would have to be specifically applied to some sort of trap, and it would have to be used along with another strategy for control. I don’t know how far I would go to say don’t get a red suitcase or red sheets, but the research hasn’t been done yet, so we can’t completely rule that out.”
McNeill hopes her research can help lead to finding better ways to trap or eradicate bedbugs. “We are thinking about how you can enhance bedbug traps by using monitoring tools that act as a harborage and are a specific color that is attractive to the bug,” said McNeill. “However, the point isn’t to use the color traps in isolation, but to use color preference as something in your toolkit to be paired with other things such as pheromones or carbon dioxide to potentially increase the number of bedbugs in a trap.”
Research is more than making bedbug tents
The research project took several years. “I completed this study in 2012. However, shortly thereafter someone published another study very similar to mine,” said McNeill. As she read the study, she noticed that other scientists had put all the life stages of bedbugs together in one group as they did color tests, and they did not include females in their color choice experiments. “My research went a step further to investigate different factors such as gender, life stage, aggregation and nutritional status that could affect bed bug color choice,” she explained.
She decided to submit her paper for publication, pointing out the differences in her own study, and was ultimately accepted by the Journal of Medical Entomology with revisions. Completing the revisions as a full-time teacher was challenging, but three years later, with the help of her husband, Union College engineering professor Dr. Seth McNeill, Dr. Corraine McNeill revised her paper and re-submitted it.
The article, “Behavior Responses of Nymph and Adult Cimex lectularius (Hemiptera:Cimicidae) to Colored Harborages,” co-authored by her husband, along with Roberto M. Pereira, Phillip Koehler and Rebecca Baldwin, has drawn attention this week from a variety of news outlets around the world. In the past few days, McNeill has done interviews with Newsweek, CNN International, Entomology Today, Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Australian News Agency—Melbourne, The Times (London) and several more. Her work has been featured in other sources including, but not limited to: BBC News, CNN, Time Magazine, The Smithsonian, Science Magazine, Nature World News, The Chicago Tribune, Pub Med Health, Health and Global News, Science Daily, International Business Times, The Washington Post, Discovery News, Self Magazine, Women’s Health and Elle Decor.
“God will put you in the most unexpected places and you will find it’s where you were meant to be,” McNeill said, happy to be sharing her love of bugs with her Union College students.“I have always loved teaching. Ever since I was a little girl and would line my teddy bears up and teach to them,” McNeill explained. “Union was the obvious choice because I knew I wanted to work at an Adventist college where I would have the opportunity to teach and inspire my students while promoting Christian scholarship.”
By Megan Wehling, student writer